Breaking the “Good Girl” Cycle

How perfection is Sabotaging Your Potential

If you grew up being praised for being a “good girl”—polite, hardworking, responsible—it probably felt like a compliment. You did what was expected, met (and exceeded) standards, and became someone people could rely on. But somewhere along the way, that identity started to feel more like a trap than a badge of honor.

Maybe you hesitate to take risks because you fear failing. Maybe you say yes to commitments you don’t have time for because you hate disappointing people. Maybe you measure your worth by how productive or accomplished you are.

That’s the “good girl” cycle at work. And at its core? Perfectionism.

For many high-achieving women, perfectionism isn’t just a personal quirk—it’s a deeply ingrained mindset shaped by years of conditioning. It tells us that success equals approval and mistakes equal failure. It convinces us that if we just work harder, do more, and never let anyone down, we’ll finally feel enough.

But that day never comes, because perfectionism is a moving target. And if left unchecked, it can quietly sabotage your confidence, creativity, and ability to take up space in the world.

How Perfectionism Keeps You Stuck

Perfectionism often masquerades as ambition or a strong work ethic, but its real impact is far more limiting. Instead of helping you succeed, it holds you back in ways you may not even realize.

It Stops You from Trying New Things
Perfectionism thrives on the fear of failure. If you believe that every attempt must be flawless, you may avoid new challenges altogether. Whether it’s a career move, a creative project, or speaking up in a meeting, perfectionism tells you, If you can’t do it perfectly, why do it at all?

article continues after advertisement

It Keeps You Overcommitted
Many perfectionists struggle to say no. The idea of disappointing others or falling short of expectations feels unbearable. This leads to constant overcommitment—saying yes to work projects, family obligations, and social requests until your own needs are squeezed out entirely.

It Creates a Constant Sense of Self-Doubt
No matter how much you achieve, perfectionism makes it impossible to feel satisfied. Instead of celebrating your successes, you fixate on what you could have done better. Even external praise doesn’t fully sink in because you always see the flaws.

The result? You are never fully present in your own accomplishments.

The Roots of Perfectionism

Perfectionism doesn’t appear out of nowhere. For many women, it starts early.

From a young age, girls are often rewarded for being well-behaved, agreeable, and high-achieving. While boys are encouraged to take risks and be resilient, girls are often praised for being responsible and diligent. This creates a subtle but powerful message: success comes from following the rules and avoiding mistakes.

As we grow older, those same patterns follow us into adulthood—only now, the stakes feel higher. Whether in careers, relationships, or personal growth, perfectionism tells us to play it safe and avoid anything that might expose us to criticism or failure.

But here’s the truth: perfectionism doesn’t protect us from failure—it just limits our potential.

How to Break the Cycle
If perfectionism has been running the show for years, breaking free won’t happen overnight. But shifting your mindset—even in small ways—can make a big difference.

1. Start Before You’re Ready
Perfectionism convinces you to wait until you feel fully prepared, confident, or qualified before taking action. The problem? That moment may never come. Instead of waiting to feel ready, start now. You’ll build confidence through action, not before it.

article continues after advertisement

2. Redefine Mistakes as Growth
One of the most effective ways to loosen perfectionism’s grip is to shift how you view mistakes. Instead of seeing them as failures, reframe them as essential data points. Every mistake is an opportunity to learn, adjust, and improve.

3. Set Boundaries and Protect Your Time
If you struggle with saying no, practice setting small boundaries. Start with low-stakes situations—declining a minor request or setting a limit on how much time you give to a task. Over time, it will feel more natural to prioritize your needs without guilt.

4. Focus on Progress, Not Perfection
Done is better than perfect. Progress is better than overthinking. Instead of aiming for flawless execution, focus on forward movement. Small steps add up, and even imperfect efforts get you further than waiting for the “perfect” time.

You Don’t Have to Prove Your Worth
Breaking the “good girl” cycle isn’t about doing more—it’s about unlearning the idea that your worth is tied to perfection. You don’t have to be flawless to be valuable. You don’t have to say yes to everything to be worthy of respect. You don’t have to prove yourself to take up space.

The most successful, confident people aren’t the ones who never make mistakes. They’re the ones who keep going despite them.

So if you’ve been waiting for permission to let go of perfectionism—this is it.

Feeling stuck in in cycle where your worth is tied to your latest accomplishment? Check out my free Growth Roadmap – a step by step, science-based workbook designed to help high-achieving women let go of over-commitment and find their purpose. You can access it here.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

How Can We Help?

I’m interested in one-on-one support (therapy/coaching)

I’m a mental health professional interested in continuing education

I’m interested in booking Shannon for a speaking engagement

I’m a journalist interested in interviewing Shannon for an interview?

I’m reaching out on behalf of a clinic or organization

Or send me a message (scroll to contact form at the bottom of the page)

I am interested in better understanding my personality and meeting with Dr. Shannon for 1-2 coaching sessions to help align my traits with my personal and professional goals
I’m an interested in a course of therapy to address difficulties that are interfering with my quality of life.